贝多芬钢琴奏鸣曲的录音版本漫谈 [复制链接]

这套值得关注


在amazon上评价很好.见http://www.amazon.com/review/product/B000009CY6/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt/104-6576172-6447968?%5Fencoding=UTF8&showViewpoints=1

全部试听:http://www.amazon.com/Beethoven-Complete-Sonatas-Diabelli-Variations/dp/samples/B000009CY6/ref=dp_tracks_all_1/104-6576172-6447968#disc_1

继续探询之旅^_^

还有一套:

在amazon的评价也很高.见http://www.amazon.com/review/product/B0001Z4PUK/ref=dp_top_cm_cr_acr_txt/104-6576172-6447968?%5Fencoding=UTF8&showViewpoints=1
试听:http://www.jpc.de/jpcng/classic/detail/-/hnum/3765870?rk=classic&rsk=hitlist

转贴一个比较新和全的按演绎者划分的贝多芬钢琴奏鸣曲全集的录音版本,供同好参考

Beethoven's 32 piano sonatas: 40 sets
Arrau
Ashkenazy
Backhaus
Barenboim on DG
Barenboim on EMI
Brendel on Vox
Brendel on Philips ADD
Brendel on Philips DDD
Buchbinder
Ciani
Ciccolini
Fischer, Annie
Frank
Goode
Gulda mono
Gulda stereo
Heidsieck
Hobson
Jando
Kempff 1950s
Kempff 1960s
Kovacevich
Kuerti
Lill
Lipkin
Lucchesini,Andrea
Nat
O'Conor
Oland, Anne
Perl
Pludermacher,Georges
Pommier
Roberts
Schnabel
Sheppard
Sherman
Steinberg,Michael
Taub
Willems
Yokoyama

请与Patzak前辈2002 年时在<爱乐人,走四方>上的帖子对照:

(转贴,谢Patzak前辈)

找到一個尚算齊全的 Complete Recordings of Beethoven's 32 Piano Sonatas 目錄, 供眾樂友參考. 它主要是以單一位鋼琴家的錄音來計算, 並按英文姓氏來排列的.
1/. Arrau, Claudio / Philips (11 CD set). 1967, 13 LP set was Philips 6747035 1960's
2/. Ashkenazy, Vladimir / Decca (10 CD set: 2LC10 443-706). Includes Andante Favori 1970's - 1980's 10h, 41m
3/. Backhaus, Wilhelm / Decca (8 CD set). 1970, 10 LP set was: London CSP 2 (CS 6683-6692) 1958-69. 1953 (op.106)
4/. Badura-Skoda, Paul / Musical Heritage Society OR B 375-385 (11 LPs) 1970
5/. Barenboim, Daniel / EMI (10 CD set).1970, 14 LP set: Angel SNLV 3755 1965-69 11h, 27m
6/. Barenboim, Daniel / DG (9 CD set reissue).Originally 12 LPs, then 12 CDs 1980's 11h, 07m
7/. Binns, Malcolm (fortepianos) / L'Oiseau Lyre (LPs only) 1980
8/. Brendel, Alfred / Vox-Turnabout (LPs reissued on CDs) 1958-64
9/. Brendel, Alfred / Philips (11 CD set).Originally 13 LPs. Includes Andante Favori 1978
10/. Brendel, Alfred / Philips (10 CD set) 1992-6 10h, 58m
11/. Buchbinder, Rudolf / Teldec (8 CD set) 1980's
12/. Fischer, Annie / Hungaraton (CD) 1970's
13/. Frank, Claude / Music & Arts MUA 640 (CD reissue). Orig. 12 LP set: RCA Victrola VICS 9000 1970
14/. Goode, Richard / Nonesuch (10 CD set) 1980's 10h, 12m
15/. Gulda, Friedrich / Decca LPs 1950's
16/. Gulda, Friedrich / Philips (9 CD set). 11 LP set was Amadeo & Orpheus labels (OR B 116-126) 1967
17/. Heidsieck, Eric / EMI Classics (4 83427 2) 1970's?
18/. Hobson, Ian / Zephyr (9 CD set) 1992-6 10h, 30m
19/. Houstoun, Michael / Morrison Music Trust, New Zealand (www.trustcd.com) 1995-7
20/. Hungerford, Bruce / Vanguard 1968-74
21/. Jando, Jeno / Naxos (10 CDs) 1980's
22/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG 1930's (mono)
23/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG (8 CD set) 1951-2 (mono)
24/. Kempff, Wilhelm / DG (8 CD set*, also a 9 CD set**). Orig. 10 LP set (1964): KL 42-51 1962-4 9h, 54m*; 9h 57m**
25/. Kuerti, Anton / Odyssey (Orig. 13 LP set: Y 34646-34649, Rec. by Aquitaine Records) 1976
26/. Kuerti, Anton / Analekta-Fleur De Lys 24010 (CD) 1995
27/. Lill, John / ASV Quicksilva (CDs) 1970's
28/. Nat, Yves / EMI (8 CD set) 1954-5 (mono)
29/. Nikoleyeva, Tatiana / Olympia (UK) (CDs) 1980's
30/. O'Conor, Jon / Telarc (9 CD set) 1980's
31/. Perl, Alfredo / Arte Nova (10 CD set) 1990's 11h, 46m
32/. Pommier, Jean-Bernard / Erato 1990's
33/. Rangell, Andrew / Dorian (CDs) 1990's
34/. Roberts, Bernard / Nimbus (9 CD set) 1980's 10h, 45m
35/. Schnabel, Artur / EMI (8 CDs).Also on Pearl, Arkadia (8 CDs) 1932-7 (mono)
36/. Sherman, Rusell / Gm Recordings - #5001 (CDs) 1993-7 10h, 52m
37/. Silverman, Robert / Orpheum Masters KSP830 (10 CD set). B?sendorfer Reproducing Piano 2000
38/. Steinberg, Michael / Elysium
39/. Taub, Robert / Vox (CDs) 1990's
40/. Willems, Gerard / ABC (9 CD set) (http://www.beethoven-sonatas.com/) 1997-2000
整整四十個不同時代的錄音, 洋洋大觀也! : )
另Emil Gilels 在DGG 的Beethoven Piano Sonatas 錄音, 的確不全, 看下列資料附記之(三) , 便知其詳矣.
(一) Gieseking, Walter / EMI. Completed two-thirds of a cycle before his death in 1956.
(二) Gieseking, Walter / Tahra. Missing sonatas 4, 5, 7, 20, 22. These are from 1949 broadcasts. He recorded all 32, but tapes of some are lost.
(三) Gilels, Emil / DG. Missing nos. 1, 9, 22, 24, 32. Died before completing cycle.
(四) Gould, Glenn / SONY. Missing nos. 4, 11, 19-22, 25-28
(五) Kovacevich, Stephen / Cycle in progress on EMI
(六) Pollini, Maurizio / DGG Recorded nos. 11-15, 17, 21, 25-32. DGG is considering having Pollini complete the cycle (according to a DG internet chat).
(七) Serkin, Rudolf / SONY. Recorded nos. 1, 6, 8, 12-14, 16, 21, 23, 26, 30-32. Also recorded 30-32 on DG
(八) Solomon (1952-6) / EMI (Testament reissues). Recorded nos.1,3,7,8,13,14,32,17,18,21,22,26-32. Suffered a stroke in 1956 before he could complete the cycle.
而其中 28/. 法國鋼琴家 Yves Nat ( 1890-1954 ) 的 8 CDs 合集, 編號為 CZS 7 62901 2 , 當日是特廉的售價, 而Artur Schnabel 的, 卻是中價. 我因為覺得已擁有了後者的劃時代之演繹, 所以就沒買下Yves Nat 這套CDs 了.
但事實上, 我又好想听听Yves Nat 的演繹, 所以便買了一張他彈奏"Appassionata" , "Pathetique" 及 "Moonlight" 的 EMI References CDH 5 61012 2 單張 CD 了.
印象並不太深: 觸鍵輕盈, 做句一般, 歌唱性不足, 与 Walter Gieseking 同一曲目, 同一唱片公司 ( EMI ) 的出品, 有天壤雲泥之別!
當然, 這是我多年前之感受, 況且又是極個人之看法而已. 能夠有機會多听听不同風格的演繹, 恐怕才是人生的一大樂事! : )

Schiff的贝钢奏出了第5卷了;P

原帖由 PFM 于 2007-11-11 9:21:00 发表 原帖由 kbohm 于 2007-11-10 22:46:00 发表 06年确实再版过立体声的那套，单声道的也出了吗？有没有详细一点的信息？先谢过了！ 是单声道版 我去找张下面底图

图来了

it is Italy set……how about the sound ?

STOP PIRATES，quite amazing logo!;P

原帖由 PFM 于 2007-11-13 19:19:00 发表 原帖由 PFM 于 2007-11-11 9:21:00 发表 [quote] 原帖由 kbohm 于 2007-11-10 22:46:00 发表 06年确实再版过立体声的那套，单声道的也出了吗？有没有详细一点的信息？先谢过了！ ......

多谢了。这版见过的，好象02年出的，网上标价和日版差不多贵，现在决定还是买立体声的了。刚在网上买下巴老1966年在萨尔茨堡的音乐会录音，orfeo出的，内容挺吸引人，两首巴赫的作品（名字忘了），莫扎特第5，第11钢奏，贝多芬热情和op.111，我只是纳闷一张唱片怎么容下这么多内容，时间怎么算都应该超过80分钟了。

顶。作品大好，多收几套无妨。

这几天在广州听过白建宇的同志们能否谈谈？

谁听过这个？

也推介Orfeo
C808109L(9CD=5CD 價) {2010英國留聲機大獎銘盤}
貝多芬 : 鋼琴奏嗚曲(全集 ) / <英雄>變奏曲(op.35) /
<迪亞貝里> 變奏曲(op.120) /
小品曲 (op.126)
古爾達 (Friedrich Gulda) 鋼琴
l
“維也納鋼琴三傑”中最具個性的音樂家
l
六○年代奧地利廣播電台珍貴存檔錄音
l
演繹 & 技巧無懈可擊;琴音錯落有緻,音樂感十足
原裝德國，原廠母帶精心轉製

ls正宗好东西