舍我其谁、谁与争锋！DG、EMI、SONY/BMG三大公司的肖邦全集大比... [复制链接]

原帖由 古典之最168 于 2010-2-21 2:04:00 发表 歐頌日後也從1989到2000年間，花了12年的時間，為另一個已經倒閉的廠牌灌錄了蕭邦作品全集，今年也再度浮現，這些他EMI留下的早期錄音，正好是一個鮮明的對比。

Ohlsson为Hyperion录了不少肖邦。不过Hyperion还没倒闭吧。

原帖由 bluesky 于 2010-2-21 15:01:00 发表 我也一直想买，可惜广东货一直不见踪影。。。

越是新录音，广东货里就越少见，炒来炒去都是老冷饭，看得人胃也缩小了不少

原帖由 bluesky 于 2010-2-21 14:27:00 发表 布列查兹 最新的Chopin钢协怎么样？好像评价很不错。

不是不错，可能是最近几年最好的肖邦钢协录音了。

哈哈，老李开小差，偷偷上网。。。。
啥时候把碟借来听听，我听过试听，感觉不错。

原帖由 古典之最168 于 2010-2-21 12:44:00 发表 按照你的分析，SONY/BMG那套有鲁宾斯坦、傅聪、李赫特，应该更符合你的胃口才对啊，为啥选DG那套？

呵呵，因为DG旗下的阿格丽希、齐尔曼、波利尼都是我喜爱的钢琴家，他们都有肖邦钢琴大赛获奖背景，在DG都有杰出的肖邦录音。此外全集中吉波尔斯坦的马祖卡也让我耳目一新。
而且DG在做全集的版本选择上很用心细致，在DG的贝多芬全集上就看得出来。

原帖由 bluesky 于 2010-2-21 14:27:00 发表 布列查兹 最新的Chopin钢协怎么样？好像评价很不错。

http://bbs.hifi168.com/showtopic-169171.aspx

SONY 如果没有ＲＵＢＩＮＳＴＥＩＮ就好了，因为已经有他在ＲＣＡ的１１ＣＤ，还不如全是傅聪的，起码我没听过

ＤＧ也是同样，ＰＯＬＬＩＮＩ的单张都全了

原帖由 chopin 于 2010-2-21 14:16:00 发表 看来即使在肖邦资源上，DG的王者地位也是不容撼动的。EMI一多半都是奥尔森的录音，此公是历届肖邦大赛冠军中弹的最不像肖邦的，也许当年肖邦如果不去巴黎而去了好莱坞会是这副德行，至于sony，剩饭都快馊了，而且基本都是笨重的模拟录音，这对肖邦来说几乎是致命的。

正是！

选2~

我已经买了肖邦的鲁宾斯坦那套，该怎么补齐尽量不重复呢？

有谁能介绍下EMI那套里面的钢琴家吗？小弟孤陋寡闻

我也对2比较感兴趣。1、3重复的版本太多了。

维基百科上的简介：

Garrick Ohlsson (born April 3, 1948 in New York) is an American classical music pianist.

Ohlsson was the first American to win first prize in the International Frédéric Chopin Piano Competition, in 1970. He also won first prize at the Busoni Competition in Italy and the Montreal Piano Competition in Canada. Ohlsson was awarded the Avery Fisher Prize in 1994 and received the 1998 University Musical Society Distinguished Artist Award in Ann Arbor, Michigan.

Ohlsson began his studies at the age of eight at the Westchester Conservatory of Music in White Plains and, at the age of 13, began studying at the Juilliard School. His musical development has been influenced in completely different ways by a succession of distinguished teachers, most notably Claudio Arrau, Olga Barabini, Tom Lishman, Sascha Gorodnitzki, Rosina Lhévinne and Irma Wolpe. Ohlsson is noted for his masterful performances of the works of Mozart, Beethoven, and Schubert, as well as the Romantic repertoire.

Ronald Bertram Smith (3 January 1922 – 27 May 2004) was an English classical pianist, composer and teacher, born in London. He entered the Royal Academy of Music at the age of 16 with the Sir Michael Costa Scholarship for composition, after leaving the academy he studied privately in Paris with Marguerite Long, while also taking an external BMus degree from Durham University.[1] He was a champion of piano works from the romantic period; most notably those of Charles-Valentin Alkan, of whom he also wrote a biography. Several CDs of his playing are available, most notably those of Alkan's works and of Frédéric Chopin's Études Opp. 10 and 25. He taught the piano for many years at The King's School, Canterbury.

Smith died in Saltwood.

Smith算是Alkan专家吧，貌似是他把Alkan作品“发扬光大”的。

Cécile Ousset (born 23 January 1936) is a French pianist.

Cécile was born in Tarbes, France, and gave her first recital at the age of five, subsequently studying at the Paris Conservatoire with Marcel Ciampi (who had formerly taught Yaltah and Hephzibah Menuhin) where, aged only fourteen, she was awarded first prize in the piano graduation class of 1950. She has won major prizes in numerous international competitions including the Marguerite Long-Jacques Thibaud in Geneva, the 4th prize in the Queen Elisabeth Music Competition in Belgium (in 1956, when other contestants included Vladimir Ashkenazy who won the 1st prize, John Browning, Lazar Berman, Tamás Vásáry and Peter Frankl), the Busoni and the Van Cliburn.

Cécile has always had a great interest and love for teaching and coaching young talent. This has resulted in many Master Classes in the United States, Canada, Europe, Australia and the Far East. Participation in her annual Master class sessions, held since 1984 in the beautiful medieval village of Puycelsi in south-west France, are eagerly sought after. She is a frequent adjudicator for major competitions such as Van Cliburn, Rubinstein, Leeds and Bremen. She is particularly noted for her recordings of Ravel, Chopin, Liszt, Rachmaninoff and Debussy.

In December 2006, Ousset retired from public performance due to health problems related to her back.

Garrick Ohlsson 居然得了那么多个大奖冠军哦，为啥红不起来呢？

估计因为他是美国人吧，大俗话说，文化底蕴不够。虽然我也不明白啥是个文化底蕴，哈哈。

不错，以后就能在YLJ中发现EMI包子的身影了.......

EMI的那套集中了很多奥尔森的肖邦录音，要我就选这套了。
奥尔森也是肖邦大赛的冠军，出身不错，听过两张，觉得挺好

对于资深乐迷，只好选EMI那套了。因为鲁宾斯坦、波里尼等早就买全了，而奥尔森的录音却很少见。