原帖由 chrisspher 于 2016/3/14 8:37:00 发表
[quote] 原帖由 myshirley 于 2016/3/13 20:59:00 发表
看来楼主有洁癖，不愿意收包子。而我正相反，喜欢偷懒，已经捡了4、5个包子了（海老，小肖，康德拉申，巴尔夏伊，罗日杰斯特文斯基）。
另外，PHILIPS的那张肖八，音高好像是存在问题，后来Regis或Alto重出了这张并调整了音高：
This incredible performance |
没错，速度也不同，Regis版各乐章时间：
I
25:15
II
6:21
III
6:25
IV
9:51
V
13:19
DSCH Journal" regarding this once famous Philips release:
"Mravinsky's last recording of the work, from his final year as the Leningrad Philharmonic's principal conductor, has had a troubled history on compact disc. Philips were the first to release it, in 1989 (422 442-2). By the time listeners with perfect pitch noted that Philips' remastering was a semitone sharp, the release had already won critical acclaim, and it is undoubtedly firmly entrenched in the libraries of thousands who have never discovered that the disc is flawed. This matters. Although it is true that listeners without perfect pitch are unlikely to suspect that anything is amiss with a recording that is a semitone sharp or flat, it is not true that the effect is imperceptible to them.
As the pitch error is caused by incorrect transfer speed, a performance transferred sharp is faster than at the correct pitch, and will be interpreted by even the most tone-deaf listener as having greater "drive". Most listeners will also describe the sharp recording as "brighter" or "airier". Furthermore, the track timings that reviewers often use as a cue to interpretation will be misleading".
